I was expecting that the last line of Reply No. 6 would excite comment, but my sense of humour, weaned on service in WW2, where deeply buried subtlety could be found, makes me realise that my sense of humour is not necessarily that of others. Here is the author of the Dorsetshire Regiment's Great War History, a regiment recruited from Thomas Hardy's beautiful county and the home of Lawrence of Arabia, having "a dig" at those battalions recruiting in the industrial north. Perhaps the writer was mindful of the support given to the Manchesters in 1917 when the Dorsets captured Holnon and went on to take Cepy Farm which enabled the 2nd Manchesters to capture a trench in the Hindenburg Line. Just a thought, of course. PhilipG.